Janet Pearce,
University of Plymouth
Suzanne McLaughlin, University of Ulster
(Click on the
title to access as a PDF document)
SUMMARY
The School
of Biological Sciences in Plymouth University runs a short off campus
event which consists of a one day trip for students to get to know each
other and the surrounding environment of Plymouth. Staff and students
go on a short boat trip from Plymouth to the other side of the Tamar estuary
so that staff and students can become acquainted with each other in a
more informal environment than the university.
Keywords:
induction, off-campus, socialise
INTRODUCTION
Increasing
importance is being placed on the management of students moving into higher
education. As the types of students entering higher education change so
the management of these students needs also to change. Modularisation
has led to the development of large shared modules at level 1 as institutions
benefit from economies of scale. In BioScience courses a first year class
size might commonly be of 200 students compared with a secondary school
class size of 20. Some students require help to deal both academically
and socially with such changes in the scale of their learning environment.
Individuals
vary considerably in their ability to socialise, especially when thrust
into the strange surroundings of a new educational institution. An attempt
to include social activities early in the course increases the extent
to which a student is socially integrated into the academic community.
This also leads to greater goal and institutional commitment, reducing
the probability of dropping out (Grosset, 1991).
RELEVANCE TO THE STAR GUIDELINES
At its outset
the STAR project researched, produced and published a set of guidelines
based on the causes of student attrition and which pointed the way towards
possible good practice. The STAR guidelines relevant to this case study
are 2.4 and 2.5:
2.4
Induction events should provide the foundations for social interactions
between students and the development of communities of practice.
2.5 Induction activities should promote the development
of good communication between staff and students.
Cook, et al.
2005
THE PRACTICE
The School
of Biological Sciences has been running a boat trip since about 1989 and
prior to this they ran a coach outing. The practice did not arise out
of a problem but was designed to get students to know each other. The
initial resource implications consisted of the hiring of a coach, which
then became the hiring of a boat.
Initial induction
within the School of Biological Sciences lasts one week. Activities include
meetings with programme coordinators and personal tutors, registration
and introductory laboratory skills, meetings with welfare and other university
services and a quiz. The quiz is run as a fun event, but it also covers
some topics in basic biology. Feedback on their performance is given to
personal tutors to discuss any deficiencies and potential improvements.
The boat trip runs on the final day (Friday).
For the trip
the students and staff meet at the university and walk down to a jetty
in the Barbican area of Plymouth (approx a 10-15 min walk). They board
the boat and travel across to the other side of the River Tamar, which
is approximately a 20-30 minute trip. On the other side of the estuary
the students walk to Mount Edgcumbe Country Park where there is a choice
of activities. Those enrolled for Marine Biology separate and investigate
the shoreline. Those enrolled for degrees in Biology are given a walking
tour leaflet (see Appendix 1) and go for a tour around the park to look
at their surroundings. The leaflet includes some biological notes which
indicate features of interest as they walk around. The tour includes panoramic
views of Plymouth. Approximately 25 % of the students go on the tour.
For the students who prefer not to go on the tour there is a coffee bar
and restaurant available where they can socialise. The students make their
own way back to Plymouth on a local pedestrian ferry. Staff are normally
available in the country park for between 3 and 4 hours.
The idea behind
the practice is that staff and students can mingle in a casual atmosphere
and students can reflect on the week’s induction and ask any questions
about things that still concern them. The students will have previously
been working in groups during the week doing various laboratory-based
practicals and this is a chance to get to know more of their classmates
and staff before formal classes begin the following week.
The trip is
very simple in its design and there is little staff effort in planning
the trip other than hiring the boat and getting staff members to turn
up. However, a small inexpensive trip such as this can help form social
groups among the students and therefore help them integrate more quickly
into the Higher Education environment.
RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS
Last year (2004)
there were 180 students and 9 staff on the trip. The trip across the river
is paid for by the School and the return trip (£1.20) is paid for
by the students themselves.
EFFECTIVENESS
The trip is
not evaluated in a formal way but the students are asked casually about
their experience and what they thought of it. From those asked it seems
that the trip is well liked. The students recognise the fact that it was
organised for them and appreciate this.
STAFF
AND STUDENT OPINIONS
The general
opinion of the staff seems to be that they enjoy the trip and the chance
to talk to the students. They have been running induction field trips
since 1989 and obviously enjoy them. Last year 9 staff went which worked
out at approximately one staff member for every 20 students.
A focus group was held in Plymouth to collect student views. Of the 6
students present, only one did not go on the induction boat trip. Those
that did had had a positive experience. Students who did not already know
anyone thought that it was a good opportunity to meet new friends.
“…it
did get me to meet other people”
“this
is where I met a group of five or six students which I got along really
well with which was vitally important in that first week (when you are
unsure if you made the right choice)…”
“made
friends with my housemate”
Of those that
had already made a friendship
“…it
mainly involved getting to know people that I had already met better”
For students
who had already made some social contacts it may be a less rewarding experience.
One student commented:
“I
went around with my flat mate who I already knew”
The student
who was unable to attend due to a prior commitment that day did acknowledge
the following:
“I
would have liked to attend though, as it was a good opportunity to get
more guidance, answer any questions still on your mind and to become
acquainted with others from the course”
PROPOSED FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS
If funding
were available the staff would like to take the students on a residential
trip to further promote group cohesion. They note that the marine biology
students have always had good group dynamics, primarily because a diving
course is included in the curriculum. All the students meet at the diving
and sailing centre and so get to know each other quite well.
Staff are
also hoping to integrate some of the postgraduate induction programme,
in particular to bring postgraduates on the boat trip to facilitate integration
between them and the undergraduates.
CONCLUSION
Induction is
more than students receiving information about the course and getting
to recognise a few academic faces. Induction is an important part of students
establishing themselves rapidly in a new social context. It is in the
interests of students and good working practices that student social groups
form. This promotes communities of learning and initiates a group ethos
that will be a valuable component of collaborative working throughout
the course. Attempting to promote social cohesion with the distractions
and anxieties of the first few days of a new course in a new institution
is challenging. Removing a student group to an interesting and relaxing
environment is an effective way of achieving both an element of relevant
academic experience and promoting cohort cohesion.
CONTEXT
Institutional
context |
- The University of
Plymouth has an educational history dating back to 1862
- In 2003/4 it had
15291 full time and 6115 part-time undergraduates
- There are 936 academic
staff
|
Departmental
context |
- Within the School
of Biological Sciences there are approximately 315 Biology undergraduate
students
- 42% male 58% female,
68% 18-20yrs old, 4% >31 yrs old)
- A significant proportion
of students now lives at home
- From a survey of travel
times, 90% live less than 30 minutes away with only 7% living
more than 1hour away
- Entry requirements
vary from 280 points (BC at A level) for specialised degrees such
as Marine Biology to 160 points (CC) for less specialised degrees
such as Biological Sciences. About 80% of entrants are admitted
on the basis of their A level (or Highers) qualifications
- Of the 250 students
admitted in 2002/3, 20 withdrew early (8%), and 22 (9%) failed
academically
- Overall the University
of Plymouth’s retention statistics are better than its HEFCE
benchmark, particularly for mature students
|
REFERENCES
Grosset, J.
(1991), Patterns of Integration, Commitment, and Student Characteristics
and Retention among Younger and Older Students. Research in Higher Education,
32, 2159-178.
Cook, A. B.S.
Rushton, S.M. McCormick and D.W. Southall, Guidelines for the Management
of Student Transition. University of Ulster. Coleraine. Also at http://www.ulster.ac.uk/star/resources/star_guidelines.pdf
accessed 15-09-05
CORRESPONDENCE
Dr Janet Pearce Senior Lecturer, School of Biological
Sciences University of Plymouth, Drake Circus, Plymouth PL4 8AA
Email: janet.pearce@plymouth.ac.uk
Dr Susanne McLaughlin, STAR Project, University of Ulster, Cromore Road,
Coleraine, N. Ireland, BT52 1SA
email: star@ulster.ac.uk
FURTHER INFORMATION
Star Case Study: University of Ulster Residential Induction